During the summer of 2008, pandas and staff from the Wolong National Nature Reserve who’d survived the Wenchuan earthquake in May were temporarily relocated to the Bifengxia Giant Panda Base, near the small city of Ya’an. There I had several chances to visit during the 2008-2009 school year while teaching at a nearby university. A first visit was escorted by our university’s Foreign Affairs Officer, Ms. Chen, on a gorgeous autumn day. We four foreign English teachers got a weekend glimpse of the park, still absorbing its additional pandas. We mostly bypassed the parts of Bifengxia that were a sort of commercial zoo, with the kitsch that can mar the natural landscape—even more Disney than Disney. Instead, we spent most of our time wandering paths in a relatively undisturbed part of the valley, picnicking beside a small stream, only glancing on our way out at a few of the relocated pandas.
On my final Bifengxia visit, in spring 2009, I showed two American friends more extensively around the panda part of the base: the panda nursery, the juveniles’ play yards, the large enclosures for adult pandas, and the quarantine areas for pandas about to be shipped to zoos in other parts of the world. I even succumbed to kitschiness enough to buy several fake panda backpacks and snugglies for the grandchildren.
“Wow,” one friend remarked. “Zoo panda exhibits will never be the same after this.”
I agreed. We’d seen almost 60 pandas, though still in somewhat artificial settings.
The final preserve I visited, in 2010, was the panda breeding center near Sichuan’s capital city of Chengdu. Programs there were similar to those at Bifengxia, but with an even greater emphasis on pregnancies, births, and nurture of baby pandas. My husband and I were able to get within about a quarter mile of the center’s entrance by public bus. The bus disgorged us at the end of the line, where a major artery narrowed into a two-lane road. Nearby earthmoving equipment punctuated the soundscape. Construction-generated dust occluded the landscape.
A short walk brought us to the center’s entrance, where groves of trees helped reestablish a quieter atmosphere and filter out the worst of the dust. Multilingual signage pointed us over a small knoll in the direction of the pandas. When we reached the pandas’ area, the animals were cute, well-tended, and obviously both a source of pride and a generator of tourist income. Still, it seemed to me just a matter of time before this center would be forced to relocate to a less densely populated area. Though muffled, the sounds of the bulldozers could be heard not far away from the 500 acre center.
Panda breeding has made considerable strides since the Chengdu panda breeding center was first established in 1987. When I visited in 2010, the survival rate of cubs was over 70% and the breeding center no longer took pandas from the wild, but exchanged genetic material with zoos and other centers worldwide to help preserve genetic diversity. By 2006, when National Geographic Magazine explored the economics of panda breeding and research in its article “Panda, Inc.,” the number and genetic diversity of captive pandas in breeding centers and zoos worldwide was approaching the 300-animal population level that experts predicted would allow the continuation of the species in captivity indefinitely with no deterioration due to inbreeding. In 2026, the breeding center still existed and had become a major tourist attraction. Its panda population continued to increase (https://climateactapp.substack.com/p/the-pandas-of-chengdu).
Maintaining a zoo panda in the U.S. costs between 2 and 3 million dollars per year. For zoos outside China, the annual cost of a panda includes a hefty conservation fee to Chinese wildlife agencies to help with panda research and conservation efforts in their home country. Periodically, pandas that have been “rented out” to foreign zoos are returned to China for breeding and further research. Pandas’ symbolism and cuteness makes their endangered status more evident and their long-term species survival somewhat less tenuous than that of other similarly threatened species. However, these cuddly creatures beg a larger question that grows more crucial as human numbers and activity increase: What is the value of wild-bred non-human populations? What are appropriate human roles in planetary stewardship? If we could communicate with her, would 4-time panda mother Mei Xiang (who lived for many years at the Washington D.C. National Zoo before returning to China in 2023) have had a different response?